Mentor Text Wednesday: Anthology Inspiration

Mentor Text:  Pop culture anthologies, or anthologies of a thematic nature

Writing Techniques:

  •         Creative writing
  •         Fan fiction
  •         Establishing storytelling guidelines
  •         Pop culture analysis


I grew up with some pretty sweet pop culture. I’ve expressed my love for Star Wars already here, and if you’re creating something with a science fiction or superhero bent, well…you’ve probably got my attention, and will earn some of my dollars.

I can track my affinity for anthologies back to one I read a number of times as a teenager, called Shock Rock, a collection of horror stories with a rock and roll element. I’m pretty sure the promise of a Stephen King story was what drew my initial attention, but it was the idea that these were horror stories, which I loved, that were about rock and roll, which I also loved. Perfect!

It was my recent purchase of an X-Files anthology that got me thinking about anthologies as mentor texts. In many ways, they are very much the kind of thing that we do in our classrooms. An editor, in our case, a teacher, puts out a call for, or collects, a whole bunch of stories from writers, or students, that are all about the same thing. I’ve had students write stories from the perspective of another character in To Kill A Mockingbird. How far off is that from these anthologies?

As I write this, I’ve paused to pull books from my shelf, just to see what I have at home. That quick pull was eight titles. This included the X-Files and Wizard of Oz anthologies I mentioned in my last post, two zombie anthologies, a post-apocalyptic one, one of stories set in other worlds, a Batman anthology and a Star Wars book. Since I do a dystopian short story study, I know that I have two or three anthologies of those on my shelves at school. Also, I’m a book packrat, so I know that there are more anthologies like this somewhere in my house.

Screen Shot 2016-02-06 at 3.24.15 PM

Some of my favorite anthologies to share with students

And I know that I’ve taken many of them out of the library, or passed them along to fellow readers and fans. With the time that I spend in bookstores, I can attest to the fact that there are many, many more such anthologies out there. Five of the eight that I pulled from my shelf were edited by John Joseph Adams, an American science fiction and fantasy editor, whose website lists about thirty such works.

How We Might Use Them:

Creative Writing

  •         Well, it goes without saying that these anthologies would give us lots of great stories to use as mentor texts, just upon the virtue of the writing alone. I know that there are a handful of stories in my “go-to” short story folder that I’ve pulled from anthologies like these. (Bob the Dinosaur Goes to Disneyland by Joe R. Lansdale is one I love to use when we look at personification. Here’s a link to a comic adaptation.)
  •         For some writers, having established characters and worlds to work in would be welcomed. I know that often, creating characters is challenging for some students. As I watch my own daughters play, I see them borrow established characters from their favorite stories to use in the new narratives they create. They do this without prompting, and I’m always amazed at the incredible drama and adventures the PAW Patrol Pups and Octonauts get up to in our living room. By allowing students to work with established characters and worlds, then we relieve some of the pressure to create. They can focus on the narrative instead of forming character.
  •        I’m realizing, for the first time this year, my full plan with our dystopian story study. It’s the first year we’ve gotten to actually writing our own stories. In conversations with my students as they are planning and writing, we’re referencing so many of the stories we read. A common conversation has been around exposition in the beginning of our stories. Vonnegut’s “Harrison Bergeron” has such an amazing opening line for a dystopian short story: “The year was 2081, and everybody was finally equal.” Boom. Our when is established, and our utopian ideal stated in less than ten words. I’m curious to see how many stories will use a similar tactic.

Fan Fiction

  •         Oz Reimagined could inspire writers to expand the work that they’ve studied. My Mockingbird fan fiction assignment asks them to look at the events of the novel from a different perspective than Scout’s. What if I asked them to tell other stories from Maycomb? What if we came back to Maycomb after the events of Mockingbird? What if we write pieces that start with the question of “What if…” and had our young writers making some changes, and writing about the ramifications of those changes?

Establishing Storytelling Guidelines & Pop Culture Analysis

  •         When engaged in characterization, to write effectively, it is important that students know the character they are writing well. Though it may not necessarily pay off in the story that they write this time, they have to “get,” say Batman, to write a Batman story. They need to think, like I often do, “What would Batman do?” They have rules to work within. If you’ve spent much time in any fandom, then you know that deviating in any way is met with much criticism. That kind of community in writing, if we can channel it positively, might be fun in a classroom!
  •       There are other story elements that they’ll need to consider as they write. If they are writing a piece in an existing world, they have “rules” to follow. The setting is set, as are the characters and many events. Students would need to understand those things to write pieces that work for that world. So, not only are we able to look at writing, but we’re also able to study a world, and analyze pop culture texts to give us those rules to work within.
  •         I think it would be a really rich activity to have students act as editors as well. Imagine taking a period or two to establish the requirements for inclusion in such an anthology.  I did it for my students writing dystopia, but in retrospect, wouldn’t it have been a better lesson had we discussed what makes a good dystopian story?

I just remembered another anthology I have somewhere here called Geektastic: Stories from the Nerd Herd, which is an anthology of stories about geeky things. Through the magic of Amazon, I was informed that an anthology called 21 Proms exists, and 13: Thirteen Stories That Capture the Agony and Ecstasy of Being Thirteen. I guess whatever we want to have students write, we can probably find an anthology that would give us good examples, or one that would give us inspiration for topics to write about.

That Amazon click-through was almost a bad idea, because I almost bought more books. Many of these anthologies I’ve grabbed for myself as a geeky reader. It wasn’t until I started thinking about mentor texts that I realized the teaching potential they hold.

There’s one more thing about this stack of geekdom that may be really important though: If a student knows I have this stack, and if we use them in class, that very well may validate their interests and passions, which for many budding writers could be the very thing that they need.

What anthologies do you have in your classroom? What anthologies exist that hold mirrors to your students and their interests and passions? How might anthologies inspire instruction and writing in your classroom?

Leave us a comment below, connect with us on Facebook, or find us on Twitter to keep the conversation going!

–Jay (@doodlinmunkyboy)

Making Time for Vocabulary Instruction that Matters

Screen Shot 2016-02-05 at 2.33.31 PM.pngYears and years ago, before I had been bitten by the writing workshop bug, I became obsessed with vocabulary instruction. My school used a series of vocabulary workbooks at each grade level, and I had witnessed how that approach didn’t worked. Not for real. Not for the long term. Some students would dutifully memorize the words, earn a high score on the quiz, and forthrightly forget most of what they had learned. Many of my students would even bother — they would sort of study the words, sort of learn some of them, earn a low quiz grade, and move on with their day.

So, I did lots of reading and research — particularly of Janet Allen — and devised a series of in-depth, meaningful approaches to actually teach vocabulary so that my students learned, retained, and used new and increasingly sophisticated words.

The problem here was time. If I spent an average of 270 minutes per week with any given class, I was using about half of those minutes just on vocabulary instruction.  Reading instruction, whole-class literature, independent reading, and writing were all squeezed into the other half. My vocabulary instruction was amazing — and my students actually loved it and looked forward to it — but it was the core of my class, and that didn’t feel right either.

After diving into writing workshop with my students, I’ll be honest, I ditched explicit vocabulary instruction altogether. I didn’t know how to do it well and do it efficiently. I quoted studies that say, “Students get the best vocabulary instruction by simply reading”, and I left it at that. A third paltry solution.

Today, I am not going to give you a list of vocabulary activities — you can easily find those on your own, and there are lots of good ones out there! (Again, check out Janet Allen’s books! She is brilliant and her work is suitable for any grade level.). What I want to offer you instead is a brief look at what we know works in vocabulary instruction and a handful of  ideas for how you can build this instruction into our current writing instruction, so that students don’t simply understand the words they read but can also use them effectively to improve their writing.
Continue reading

Mentor Text Wednesday: Anthology Introductions

MentorTextWednesdayMentor Texts:  

Sherman Alexie Speaks Out on The Best American Poetry 2015

Introduction to X-Files: Trust No One by Jonathan Maberry

Launching Rockets,” Introduction to The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015 by Joe Hill

Writing Techniques:

  •         Justifying editorial choices
  •         Expressing opinion
  •         Pop culture analysis
  •         Expressing thematic connections


I buy a lot of anthologies. Sometimes I buy them for work, for obvious reasons. Others, I buy as a reader. As I tucked into my newest purchase, the X-Files anthology Trust No One edited by Jonathan Maberry, I realized that I was holding a potential mentor text.

I flashed back to my time at teachers’ college, and an assignment I had that I really enjoyed. In a poetry course, we were tasked with creating the table of contents and writing the introduction for an anthology. I’m a big music fan, and was listening to a lot of Springsteen at the time, so I decided the world could use an anthology of the lyrics of story songs. The prof was a tough one, and getting an A on that introduction was a highlight in my life as a student.

Looking specifically, however, at the new anthology I was tucking into, I realized that I had a bunch of anthologies around various themes, like the X-Files, the land of Oz, zombies, post-apocalyptic worlds, and dystopias. A common theme running through the introductions was that the editors, and authors of these intros are fans of what they’re curating.

How We Might Use Them:

Justifying editorial choices – Obviously, we could have students creating introductions to anthologies that they curate, much like I did years ago. I’ve actually done versions of this in classes, asking students to pull together a list or piece around a theme or idea, and having them explain their choices. The biggest challenge in this was not actually the introduction, but the fact that many students may not have a deep enough reading history to pull together a “collection” to introduce. I teach thematically, and this kind of exercise also gives the students a way to express their thoughts around the theme we’ve focused on: to pull together arguments from a variety of places.

  •         There’s a gorgeous mentor moment in Alexie’s intro to The Best American Poetry 2015. Essentially, he lays out his criteria for selecting poems. If students are curating, then this would be a fantastic exercise for them to go through, individually, or collectively.

Expressing Opinion & Pop Culture Analysis – I’ve said before that a lot of our students are fans. A great use for these pieces would be to discuss that fandom, what it means to them, and their fan community.

Screen Shot 2016-02-02 at 9.23.26 AM

Maberry does this very well in his X-Files  intro:

We want to believe.

We want to know.

Watching a show as intelligent as The X-Files allows us to be partners in the conversation between those who want to know and those who are trying to keep that knowledge secret. And we let the relentlessness of Scully and Mulder drive us forward for nine seasons, two movies, comics, games, novels…

We still want to believe.

  •         Building on the expression of fan community, these introductions sometimes extend into explaining why the subject of the anthology is culturally relevant. I’ve seen numerous ones that begin with a brief history, or explanation of their subject, and then move on to illustrate the cultural resonance of the material the anthology focuses on.
  •         There is a passage in Maberry’s introduction where he aligns himself with the two principal characters of the show. This, I think, is a valuable mentor moment for students. When we engage with texts, be they written or otherwise, we often look for ourselves in them, or try to decide who we align with in the piece. (You’ve all decided which Harry Potter house you belong in, right?) Maberry shows students how to do that, and although briefly, and simply stated, it’s actually well rounded out.
  •         I know that a lot of times, we have students working on pieces of writing around a single text. We wind up with collections of essays, stories, poems and fan fiction-esque material on our desks. When I started thinking about using these introductions as a mentor text, it struck me that this would be a great way to reflectively wrap up this work. As I write this, I’ve just had students creating Illustrated Blackout poems using speeches from Macbeth as we finished studying it. Wouldn’t it be lovely if we had taken the time to gallery walk those pieces, and I had my students write an introduction that would accompany that collection? Could we do that for any pieces of writing that we’ve all done?
  •         Often, in these introductions, the editor takes a moment to explain their affinity for certain pieces. I don’t know about others, but sometimes, I have a heck of a time getting my students to express their affinity for a piece. I can see their excitement for the piece, but it’s frustrating that it doesn’t always get past, “It’s awesome.” Taking a look at an editor expressing their reasons for choice could be helpful for students.

Expressing thematic connections – As I mentioned above, I have a tendency to teach thematically in my English classes. As a result, I’m often pulling together what feel like disparate pieces, justifying how they fit under the umbrella of a single big idea. What these anthologies intentionally do is what I try to do in my classroom. They pull together a whole bunch of pieces, and unite them under a theme. Sometimes, the connections are obvious, but there are other times that the editor spends part of their introduction explaining the connections. They justify the choices they’ve made, and often, personalize the connection that they, as readers, made as they pulled the collection together. I don’t know about your classes, but getting my students to think about their reading on paper, making text-to-text connections, can be challenging, and if a model can help…

Obviously, as a reader, and as an English teacher, anthologies are part of my life. I’m noticing, however, that the way that I look at them has changed. They are no longer just collections of good things to read, or collections of potential teaching resources, but actually those things and more. Pulling things together around an idea, theme or topic is a thing that we would expect our students to do as part of the learning process. These anthologies just give us a vehicle to mentor that process.

Oh, and I’m not done with these anthologies. Remember, as you read this that I’ve really only talked about the introduction. Next week I’ll share the mentor moments inside.



Do you have any favorite anthologies? Are you aware of any anthologies that embody your students’ passions? How might you use these cultural artifacts to inspire your students and lift their writing?

Leave us a comment below, connect with us on Facebook, or find us on Twitter to keep the conversation going!

In Search of a More Meaningful, Effective, Enduring Way to Teach Grammar

Screen Shot 2016-01-31 at 9.45.25 PM

Image via

My whole teaching life I have been in search of a way to teach grammar that is meaningful, effective, and enduring.

I have tried bits and pieces of other people’s curricula for years––Kelly Gallagher’s Sentence of the Week, Nancie Atwell’s editing sheets and proofreading lists––but I’ve never been able to find my groove with these systems. And when I pore over student writing portfolios in June, I can see that my students have grown tremendously, but a lot of the writing is still grammar-rough (I’m using this term loosely––by grammar, I’m referring to all things grammar, mechanics, and usage). Not quite publishable. Still a few too many comma issues. Run-away sentences. And if I see one more misuse of the word their…

I know it could be better. Their writing. My instruction.

But how? I’ve tried almost everything! Continue reading

Books That Move Us: Reading Projects Reimagined (Dan Feigelson)

Screen Shot 2016-01-29 at 2.34.34 PM

You know how the greats always make it look easy? This is the way I feel whenever I get to listen to Katie Ray or Tom Newkirk — they say something clear and simple and beautiful and even common sense, but it absolutely rocks my world.

So it was when I read Dan Feigelson’s Reading Projects Reimagined (Heinemann 2015). After hearing Feigelson speak at NCTE about “revising” reading and his “quick and dirty reading projects”, I knew I had found a strategy for my second semester literature focus. And, quite possibly, a road into student writing about literature. And after digging into the book over winter break, my teaching world was rocked by the book’s simplicity and brilliance.

60-Second Book ReviewScreen Shot 2016-01-26 at 2.12.09 PM

Fear not — Feigelson’s “reading projects” are not rendered on poster board or as dioramas (which was my initial fear upon reading the title). It is so much more intuitive and authentic than that.  A reading project is simply a written record of  “what the student wants to think about”. And as we encourage students to pursue those lines of thought, we make them “co-conspirators in their own comprehension.”

Why haven’t I already thought of this?

Feigelson presents a simple three-step process: Continue reading

Mentor Text Wednesday: A Letter from Montreal

Mims First Snow

The author’s first snow–Image via The Concordian

Mentor Text:  A Letter From Montreal Maisonneuve Winter 2015

Writing Techniques:

  • Memoir – discussing a first
  • Writing about experiences
  • Writing around a set theme
  • Using various elements to tell a story
  • Writing strong conclusions


I’m a recovering magazineaholic.

Part of it is curiosity. I feel compelled to know what each magazine has to offer me. There are fascinating articles, cool images and design, and new learning hidden in each and every one of those periodicals.

Part of it is professional. I can archive stuff that can add to what we’re doing in class. Differing perspectives, challenging ideas, layout and presentation inspiration, to say nothing of all the mentor text opportunities… all in one package?!

I still walk into a book store, and want them all. Continue reading

Revision: A New Kind of Final Exam


Screen Shot 2016-01-23 at 10.23.11 PMInspired by Rebekah’s decision to quit grading earlier this year, I have been trying to take more risks with assessment in my own classroom. I haven’t gone grade-free quite yet, but I’m looking for more opportunities to involve my students in the assessment process. Since it is end-of-term time for many schools, I thought it would be helpful to share what I tried with my freshman classes for our semester exam in December.

The Dilemma: How can I return to writing without interrupting a performance unit? How can I assess students’ writing progress without assigning a brand new final exam essay?

My freshman curriculum is structured such that, by the time final exams roll around, my classes have moved away from writing workshop into a Romeo and Juliet performance activity that combines with a brief objective test to form their exam. I really like using the performance activity as part of the final, but every year, I feel like my final assessment shortchanges all the work students have done as writers earlier in the semester. I want my final exam to reflect students’ progress in reading, speaking, listening, and writing!

The Solution: Independent revision of past work with help from Google Apps for Education
Continue reading

An Open Call for Teacher Writers: Will You Join Us?

Screen Shot 2016-01-22 at 8.49.50 AM

This month we welcomed two amazing new teacher writers to Moving Writers — Stefanie Jochman (@msjochman), whose first post about podcasts as mentor texts knocked our socks off, and Jay Nickerson (@doodlinmunkyboy), mentor text finder extraordinaire!

As our Moving Writers family grows, we are looking to add a few more voices and perspectives to the mix. Here’s where you come in!

Are you a teacher who likes to write? Is writing instruction your passion? Would you like to join a PLN of bloggers who write about writing and connect with others who love teaching writing?

If you are interested in blogging for us, please complete this form before March 1.

We’re looking forward to hearing from you!

Allison & Rebekah

WRITING WITH MENTORSScreen Shot 2015-11-23 at 2.56.21 PM

Available on Amazon or Heinemann!

Mentor Text Wednesday: On Rey


Mentor Text:  

The Power of Rey by Nicole Sperling

What Rey Means to Me by Gabrielle Bondi

What is a Mary Sue, and does Star Wars: The Force Awakens have one? by Caroline Framke

Writing Techniques:

  • Character analysis
  • Pop culture analysis
  • Using a feminist lens to critique character and pop culture


I got two Christmases in 2015. There was the one we always get, and there there was the Star Wars one. I’m one of those people who was at the perfect age to have seen the original film as a very impressionable youngster, and grew up with those characters, reading an Expanded Universe of tales in that galaxy far, far away. I was brought up so high by hope for the prequels, and disappointed.So, The Force Awakens was obviously kind of a big deal for me.

And it put me into a bit of a social media cave, as I tried to avoid spoilers so I could enjoy the film to the max. And I did.

I have daughters, and though their exposure to Star Wars has been limited, I was excited when the initial rumblings of the presence of Meaningful Female Characters! Leia was one of the strongest female chracters in popular sci-fi, but there was always something lacking. Probably the negative effects of that bikini at Jabba’s palace. Growing up with arguably some of the greatest characters in pop culture, I wanted that for my girls.

Screen Shot 2016-01-08 at 9.49.11 AMI’m not the only one to feel this way. After seeing the film, I was able to click on a lot more around the web, and came across a lot of writing about Rey. Some gushes, some criticizes. I chose a bit of both in this mentor text packet.

“The Power of Rey” and “What Rey Means to Me” are built on praise, on finding a hero that speaks to you, specifically a female hero. For many, Rey breaks into the boy’s club of good action heroics without a love triangle or a focus on her sex appeal. These pieces deal with that, though they largely avoid the controversy that accompanies the conversation about Rey. What I like about them, and what students could use as inspiration is that they are written from a fan’s position. This is people sharing what they like about Rey, and why. There’s an element of personal narrative that justifies their appreciation of Rey.

The “Mary Sue” question is dealt with in the third article. In some ways, it may be the strongest appreciation of Rey as a gender barrier breaker since it goes into more depth discussion of the gender stereotypes, explaining what a Mary Sue is, and supporting both sides of the argument. Though ultimately, the piece decides that Rey is what the other two pieces would have you believe, it goes about it in a much more analytical fashion.

I specifically chose not to include pieces that were overtly critical of her character. That is, I chose not include them at this time. I feel like those pieces serve a different purpose, and would be a mentor text package of their own, a critical takedown of a character if you will. To me, praising a character and bashing a chracter are two separate skill sets, and could be taught as such. Now I have more mentor texts to find…

How We Might Use Them:

  • All three of these pieces give strong examples of discussing character, and what the writer likes about the character. Two hew closer to expression of fandom, while one presents a more analytical appreciation of the character.
  • The narrative style of “The Power of Rey” would give young writers a way to express themselves as part of their writing about character. As a geek, I know how all-encompassing this stuff can be. The whole experience feels like it needs to be discussed, not just the character analysis stuff your teacher wants from you. This piece shows students a way to do both.
  • “What Rey Means to Me” is a compilation of what different voices have to say about a single character. Sometimes, we teachers make a big task out of something smaller. Could students craft mini-pieces, like those in this piece, and then combine them? Consider as well, that this piece gives a variety of voices expressing similar ideas. It’s a collection of shorter mentor texts compiled, giving students options.
  • The Mary Sue piece would be a great mentor text for students to use in the course of discussing a controversial issue in pop culture, such as gender. Working with young people, we know that they have many questions and opinions to sift through and figure out. This piece lays it out very well for them, with background, point, counterpoint and conclusion.
  • Pop culture has been heavily influenced by Star Wars, and our students, if they’re fans, are accustomed to critically looking at their respective fandoms, these giant worlds of characters. These pieces are all examples of how to look at pop culture with a feminist, or gender lens. Could we not extrapolate that, and use these as mentor texts to look at pop culture through other lenses? Or our reading?

I use Star Wars to teach. Students know that I love it, and other fandoms, and they like to talk about this geeky stuff with me. Pieces like this are going to be useful in taking that interest into an academic realm, where we can geek out, and meet our outcomes. And, for my students who aren’t geeks, they also serve as great examples of how to do that character stuff I ask them to do with their reading.

Are your students into Star Wars? How might you use these pieces to help your students analyze and write about character? What other elements might these mentor texts teach? 

Leave us a comment below, connect with us on Facebook, or find us on Twitter (@doodlinmonkeyboy, @msjochman, @rebekahodell1, @allisonmarchett) to keep the conversation going! 


So, I Quit Grading — Part II Update

Screen Shot 2016-01-17 at 11.01.21 PMThis year, I quit grading almost entirely. While I still give quarterly grades (because my students have to have them!), I do not grade individual assignments. I’ve given up traditional grading for many reasons that I explain in my first post on this topic, but the biggest of the reasons is this: I don’t think traditional grading is in the best interest of my students. 

I promised you that I would keep you updated, so, now that I have lived in this experiment for a whole semester, I will share with you what I am finding out. The good, the bad, and the ugly.

The Good

More honest feedback for all

Because I am not spending so much time perseverating over numbers on a rubric, and because I know that I can’t fall back on grades to “communicate” progress, each of my students is receiving far more feedback — not just on how they are currently performing, but also ideas for how to grow, what to do next, and techniques to try next time.

Even better than a greater volume of feedback, though, I find myself free to give more honest feedback. Sometimes, it’s downright blunt. But because my students are convinced that I am on their side, I find I can tell them the truth.

For example, here is some quarterly grade feedback I recently left for two students, one who is working very hard and growing by leaps and bound, and another who tends to eek by doing the bare minimum: Continue reading