Writing Workshop 101/201: Choice

I’ve found over the years that “writing workshop” means a lot of things to a lot of people. So, what does it mean to have a writing workshop functioning in your classroom? How do you even take the first step? 

This semester, my regular every-other-Monday “beat” will focus on the fundamental building blocks of writing workshop. Each week, I’ll share an element of writing workshop, tell you why it matters, give you a few ideas for getting started if you’ve never tried it before, and give you seasoned workshoppers some ideas for taking that element to the next level.

This series will help you steadily move from “Hmmm….I might want to do that … but how?” to “Yep, this is a writing workshop!”  It will move you from “I’m doing that!” to “I’m pushing that as far as it will go.” It’s a series to share with colleagues who are interested-but-nervous, to tackle with a teacher buddy or PLC as a challenge, or to try outas a department! 


writing (3).png

Walk into any English classroom where students are writing. Is it a writing workshop? If it is, one of the very first things you would notice is that students are not all writing on a  single, universal topic. Students are making choices about their topics.

Here’s some good news: choice is one of the easiest places to start dipping your toe into the writing workshop and it’s one of the easiest places to expand once you feel like you’re ready to be a bit daring.

Why Choice?

We offer students choice for about a million reasons. Here are four:

  • Authenticity — real writers aren’t assigned topics
  • Authority — students write with passion and authority when they are writing what they know.
  • Engagement — real writers write best when they are working on topics they care about
  • Voice — our classrooms are more compassionate, democratic places when every students’ perspectives and experiences are valued and invited to the table.

In short, the more choice we can give students in their writing, the more we get of all of them.

Donald Murray, the Pulitzer-prize winning journalist and godfather of writing workshop, says everything best. He writes,

“The assignment is not the solution to a lack of student writing, it is usually the cause…Students will write well only when they speak in their own voice, and that voice can only be authoritative and honest when the student speaks of his own concerns in his own way” (129, “What, No Assignments?”)

Wading Into Choice

Feeling curious but a bit wary? Adding choice into student writing doesn’t mean having a free-for-all. Here are some ways you can dip a toe in and get started:

Get started by adding choice to in-class activities

Get used to a classroom with more choice by building choice into in-class activities of all kinds. Take what you’re already doing, and find a way to add a second option. Perhaps students can annotate their reading with notes in the margin or by color-coding with highlighters. Maybe they choose between one of three ways to get practice with their vocabulary words.   Some students could choose to draft a traditional outline of their essay or choose to outline using Post-Its as moveable pieces instead.

Adding choice in small doses will get both you and your students ready to add it in bigger doses down the road!

Get started by adding choice through Notebook Time

I know, we talk about Notebook Time incessantly here. But it is one of the fastest, strongest, easiest ways to make measurable strides in student writing.

Committing to 5-8 minutes of regular Notebook Time — daily, twice a week, every Friday — builds in writing practice and choice practice simultaneously.  Notebook Time invites students to choose how they respond to a mentor text.  Depending on the mentor text you toss out for students to play with,  they could:

Screen Shot 2018-09-19 at 5.35.11 PM

You can even start students off by suggesting ways they could potentially respond (while always offering the option for students to respond in off-script ways, too!) For example,

Screen Shot 2018-09-19 at 5.35.28 PM

Get started by adding choice to existing writing units

Take that unit you teach every year and add a second or third option. This way, students at least are getting some say in the way they approach the topic or assignment.  For instance, if your students always write a character analysis of Holden in The Catcher in the Rye, add the options of writing about Phoebe or the city of New York.

Choice 2.0

So, you and choice are old friends. You go way back. In your units of study, students always have free reign over their topic. How can you do more and take it to the next level? Here are three ideas:

Take it to the next level by instituting independent writing units

I make students a deal — write something in a genre I choose. Then next time you’ll get to write anything you want to write in the world. We just alternate. That way I can meet my objectives while also ensuring that my students are getting the most real-world practice of choosing topics and genres that inspire them.

Bonus: it’s a nice mini-break in my planning time! I make these free-choice independent writing units shorter than whole-class units, plan fewer mini-lessons,  and do even more conferring.

Take it to the next level by teaching some technique-focused writing studies in addition to your genre-focused units.

Most of us organize our writing workshop units by genre: we’re all writing op-eds! We’re all writing personal narratives! We’re all writing how-to guides!

Genre studies are important because students need genre-know-how to make their own choices of writing topic and form. But another option that allows us to give students more choice without letting them completely wild and free is to teach a unit on a specific writing technique and allow students to choose the genre through which they want to demonstrate their mastery of that technique.

What does this look like? I once taught an evidence unit — each mini-lesson was a different strategy for incorporating evidence into your writing. Students wrote arguments and information writing and even narratives that used these strategies so that their writing was chock-full of evidence.

Maybe your students need to focus on showing-not-telling. Each lesson you teach would give students another strategy for making their writing come to life with elements of narrative. Then, students would show their mastery of these skills through a poem that leans on story or through a commentary that begins with a mini-narrative. This is a great way to nudge students to make more choices in their writing because the structures of workshop are familiar, you are still holding the reigns, but there is much more variety in what students are creating.

Take it to the next level with a portfolio approach

After three semesters of genre studies, technique studies, and independent writing projects, my students will spend their last semester with me composing a portfolio. By the end of the semester they will need to write four polished pieces: at least one narrative, one piece of information writing, and one piece of argumentative/persuasive writing.

Students won’t just decide what and how. For the first time in my classroom, they will also decide when.

For each round of writing workshop, I will work with students in small groups — pulling  just the information writers together for a mini-lesson or a small group conference. Finding a mentor text to inspire just the narrative writers. We’ll feel a little bit more like the newsroom Donald Murray first envisioned for the writing workshop or Liz Prather’s brilliant project-based writing classroom.

What do you still need to know?

You’ve got questions. Concerns. Little logistical stray ends that are bothering you about CHOICE in the workshop. Submit them here — whether you’re a workshop newbie or a pro. We’ll get you an answer in an upcoming post. All questions will remain anonymous!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s